Research Article
Research Article
Characteristics of parthenogenesis in Cacopsylla ledi (Flor, 1861) (Hemiptera, Sternorryncha, Psylloidea): cytological and molecular approaches
expand article infoSeppo Nokkala, Valentina G. G Kuznetsova§, Christina Nokkala
‡ University of Turku, Turku, Finland
§ Russian Academy of Sciences, St. Petersburg, Russia
Open Access


Characteristics of parthenogenesis in Cacopsylla ledi (Flor, 1861) were analyzed using cytological and molecular approaches. In all three populations studied from Finland, i.e. Turku, Kustavi and Siikajoki, males were present at a low frequency but were absent from a population from Vorkuta, Russia. In a follow-up study conducted in the Turku population during 2010–2016, the initial frequency of males was ca. 10 % and showed no intraseasonal variation, but then dramatically decreased down to approximately 1–2 % level in seasons 2015–2016. Male meiosis was chiasmate with some traces of chromosomal fragmentation and subsequent fusions. In most females, metaphase in mature eggs included 39 univalent chromosomes which indicated apomictic triploidy. Only a small fraction of females was diploid with 13 chiasmate bivalents. The frequency of diploid females approximately equaled that of males. COI barcode analyses showed that triploid females (N = 57) and diploids (7 females and 5 males) displayed different haplotypes, demonstrating that triploid females reproduced via obligate parthenogenesis. The rarity of diploids, along with the lack of males’ preference towards diploid females, suggested that most likely diploids were produced by rare triploid females which shared the same haplotype with the diploids (not found in the present analysis). Minimum haplotype diversity was detected in the Turku population, but it was much higher in Vorkuta with some indication for the mixed origin of the population. We suggest that functional diploids produced in a parthenogenetic population can give rise either to a new parthenogenetic lineage or even to a new bisexual species.


Cacopsylla ledi , Psylloidea , apomictic parthenogenesis, triploid females, diploid females, rare males, COI haplotypes


The great majority of psyllid species are characterized by bisexual reproduction. However, some members of, at least, in two genera, Cacopsylla Ossiannilsson, 1970 and Trioza Foerster, 1848 include all-female populations and are, therefore, suggested to be parthenogenetic. These are C. ledi Flor, 1961, C. rara (Tuthill, 1944), C. myrtilli W. Wagner, 1947, C. myrtilli ssp. canadensis Hodkinson, 1978, T. pletschi Tuthill, 1944 and T. abdominalis Flor, 1861 (Ossiannilsson 1972, Hodkinson 1976, 1978, Gegechkori 1985). Parthenogenesis of this kind is called thelytoky which is characterized by the presence of females that produce only daughters without fertilization. Thelytoky can be obligatory if only parthenogenetic populations are present throughout the whole distribution range of a particular species. Nevertheless, it can be facultative if both bisexual and parthenogenetic reproduction occurs, with cyclical parthenogenesis in aphids as a well-known example (Normark 2003, Vershinina and Kuznetsova 2016).

However, identifying facultative thelytokous taxa is usually difficult. In many animal taxa the existence of so called rare males was reported for some parthenogenetic lineages (Blackman 1972, Palmer and Norton 1990, Butlin et al. 1998, Martens 1998, Rispe et al. 1999, Simon et al. 1999, Delmotte et al. 2001, Snyder et al. 2006, Domes et al. 2007, Engelstadter et al. 2011, Maccari et al. 2013, Nokkala et al. 2013). These males can be either nonfunctional, i.e. incapable of producing haploid gametes (Taberley 1988, Nokkala et al. 2013) or functional with normal gamete production (reviewed by Maccari et al. 2013). Both kinds of males were found in geographically separate populations in the parthenogenetic psyllid Cacopsylla myrtilli (Nokkala et al. 2013). Females of this species are apomictic triploids (Nokkala et al. 2008). Cytological analysis has also discovered diploid females coexisting with the rare males especially at high altitude. These rare males, although being nonfunctional, copulate randomly with both parthenogenetic and “sexual” diploid females (Nokkala et al. 2015).

The characteristics of parthenogenesis in the Holarctic species C. ledi are poorly known. The species lives on wild rosemary Ledum palustre Linnaeus, 1753, and was previously recorded from Fennoscandia, the Baltic countries, Poland, Germany, Russia, Japan and Alaska (Ossiannilsson 1992). In addition to all-female populations, populations with males are known to exist, although quantitative frequencies of males are unknown. The males share the same chromosome number 2n = 25 (24 + X) with males of the genuine bisexual psyllid species (Kuznetsova et al. 1997).

In the present study, we planned to determine the frequency of males in four populations of C. ledi. In a follow-up study we planned to find out if the frequency of males would undergo any changes either during one reproductive season or between successive seasons. In addition, we planned to analyze chromosomes in mature eggs to determine the type of parthenogenesis and details of reproduction types of females in a particular population. Intrapopulational relationships between the females and males in a population were analyzed by using DNA barcode sequences.

Material and methods


Specimens of C. ledi were collected on Ledum palustre in four geographically separate locations, Turku, Kustavi and Siikajoki in Finland and Vorkuta in Russia (Table 1). Since this study was focused on the Turku population, samples were collected there during 2010–2016.

Table 1.

Locations, number of females and males, male percentages and collection dates of C. ledi populations.

Location Females Males Male percentage Date
Kustavi 60°39'20"N, 21°18'12"E 310 4 1,3 % 1.8.2010
Siikajoki 64°39'32"N, 25°19'33"E 152 3 1,5 % 19.8.2010
Turku 60°29'56"N, 22°15'55"E no adults 22.6.2010
112 14 11,0 % 30.6.2010
149 14 8,5 % 6.7.2010
132 17 11,4 % 16.7.2010
182 17 8,5 % 26.7.2010
82 10 10,3 % 3.8.2010
72 10 12,2 % 11.8.2010
40 0 0,0 % 26.8.2011
124 14 10,1 % 19.7.2012
170 2 1,1 % 25.8.2015
78 2 2,5 % 27.7.2016
Vorkuta, Russia 67°30'N, 64°02'E 10† 0 0,0 % 6.8.2013

Cytological study

Both female and male specimens of C. ledi were collected in June, July and early August to study spermatogenesis and sex ratios in certain populations. As females carried no mature eggs at that time, they were collected later in August for cytology (Table 1). Complete bodies of male individuals were put in 3:1 fixative (96 % alcohol: glacial acetic acid) or stored in 96 % alcohol in the field immediately after collection. To allow both chromosomal and haplotype analyses of the same individuals, collected living females were taken to the laboratory and dissected individually. For every female, the abdomen was put into the fixative while the head and thorax parts were stored in alcohol. Cytology was performed following Nokkala et al. (2008). In brief, the abdomen was transferred from the fixative into a drop of 50 % acetic acid. Three to four mature eggs were extracted from the ovaries, the presence or absence of sperm in the spermatheca was recorded, and the rest of the abdomen was removed. To remove chorion, the eggs were cut in two parts with well sharpened tungsten needles. When yolk became transparent the eggs were squashed. The cover slips were removed by the dry ice method and slides were then immersed in fresh 3:1 fixative for 30 min and air dried. Air-dried slides were stained first with Schiff’s reagent for 30 min and then with 5% Giemsa for 40 min. Chromosomes were photographed with a BU4-500C CCD camera (BestScope International Limited, Beijing, China) attached to Olympus BX51 microscope (Olympus, Japan) using ISCapture Software version 2.6 (Xintu Photonics Co LTD, Xintu, China). Photographs were processed with Corel Photo-Paint X5 software.

DNA barcoding

Total genomic DNA was extracted with DNeasy Blood and Tissue Kit (Qiagen) from complete bodies or thorax parts of adults. In cases when yield was below 20 ng / µl, the extractions were concentrated by precipitation with sodium acetate according to the standard procedure and the precipitate was solubilized in distilled water in one-fourth of the original elution volume. A fragment of cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI) gene was amplified using Applied Biosystems 2720 Thermal Cycler. Initially, the C. myrtilli specific primers HybCamyCO (forward) and HybymaCCO (reverse) were used and PCR reactions were carried out as described by Nokkala et al. (2015). Later on, to check the sequence at 5’ and 3’ ends, flanking primers HybCacoCO 5’-T7Promoter(F)-CTAACCATAARACTATTGGAAC-3’ (specifically designed forward primer) and a modified HCO (Folmer et al. 1994) reverse primer HybHCOMod 5’-T3-TAAACTTCAGGGTGACAAAAAATCA-3’ were used. PCR products were purified with QIAquick PCR Purfication Kit (Qiagen) and sequenced by Macrogen Europe (Amsterdam, the Netherlands). The sequences were trimmed to span a 638 bp stretch of the gene to match the available sequences of related C. myrtilli (Nokkala et al. 2015). Sequences obtained during this study have been deposited in GenBank under the accession numbers MF978762-MF978766.


Population structure

The majority of individuals in all populations were females, while the frequency of males varied in different samples from 0 % to 12.2 % (Table 1). In Kustavi and Siikajoki, the frequencies were low, 1.3 % and 1.5 % respectively. Males were absent in the sample from Ledum in Vorkuta. In the Turku population, the frequency of males was higher, around 10 %, and showed no seasonal variation between 30.6–11.8 in 2010. The frequency remained high in 2012, but decreased dramatically to 1.1 % in 2015 and remained low in 2016. Low frequencies of males suggest that C. ledi reproduces parthenogenetically, and males represent the so-called rare males commonly found in parthenogenetic lineages.


In C. ledi males, testes have four testicular follicles, in contrast to two, which is the common number in psyllids (Kuznetsova et al. 2012). The male karyotype was earlier reported to be 2n = 25 (24+X) by Kuznetsova et al. (1997), which was confirmed by the present study (Fig. 1). In male meiosis chiasma formation is normal; hence twelve bivalents and a univalent X chromosome are seen at metaphase I. However, males heterozygous for fusions are not uncommon (Figs 2 and 3); they can carry either a single heterozygous trivalent (Fig. 2) or two such trivalents (Fig. 3) Nevertheless, these metaphases originate from different testes of the same individual, thus indicating that the chromosome breaks leading to subsequent fusions have occurred in the germ line.

Figures 1–3.

Male meiosis in C. ledi. 1 Metaphase I with normal karyotype, n = 12 + X (0) (from Kuznetsova et al. 1997) 2 Metaphase I. Arrow points to trivalent which is heterozygous for a fusion 3 Metaphase I. Arrows point to two trivalents which are heterozygous for fusions. Scale bar: 10 µm.


The chromosome number of females is most easily determined at metaphase I in mature eggs. For a closer study of the biology of females during one season, several samples were taken from the Turku population in 2010 starting on 30.6., when adults just appeared in the population (Table 1). First females with mature eggs were found not earlier than 11.8, when single mature eggs were found in very few females (Table 2). On 25.8.2015 all females carried several mature eggs in their ovaries. The egg-lying of females was studied in the laboratory using material collected in 2015. We found that females preferred to deposit their eggs on the underside of the uppermost narrow leaves of Ledum plants. This clearly indicates that C. ledi hibernates as an egg.

Cytological analysis revealed that there were two kinds of females in the population. Mature eggs of the great majority of females showed 39 univalent chromosomes at metaphase, indicating that these females were apomictic triploids (Fig. 4). There were also a small number of females with a haploid number of chiasmate bivalents, i.e. those females were diploid (Fig. 5). Typically, there was only a single terminal or subterminal chiasma per bivalent. The frequency of diploid females within a particular sample varied from 30.0 % to 2.7 %, as shown in Table 2. It is noteworthy that the approximate tenfold drop-down in the frequency of diploid females between 2012 and 2015 is similar to the decrease found in male frequencies from 10.1 % to 1,1 % (Table 1). Unfortunately, no mature eggs were found in females collected in Vorkuta.

Figures 4–5.

Female meiosis in C. ledi. 4 Metaphase from mature egg with 39 univalent chromosomes 5 Metaphase I plate with 13 chiasmate bivalents (12 + XX), sex chromosome bivalent cannot be identified. Arrows point to three overlapping pairs of bivalents. Scale bar: 10 µm.

Table 2.

Number of triploid and diploid females in Turku population.

Triploid females Diploid females Percentage of diploids Collection date
2 1 N/A 11.8.2010
14 6 30,0 % 28.6.2011
36 1 2,7 % 25.8.2015
27 1 3,6 % 21.8.2016

The absence of male mating preference

With both diploid and triploid females present in a population, it is interesting to find out whether males prefer to mate with diploid ones or, at least, can distinguish between these two. For this purpose, while making cytological preparations from females, spermathecae were also checked for the presence of sperm. However, only seven out of 71 females checked carried sperm in their spermathecae, two of them being diploids and the remaining five triploids (Table 3). This indicates that males are quite inactive in mating in general but occasionally mate either with diploids or triploids. Since the males do not discriminate against triploid females successful independent bisexual reproduction in C. ledi seems highly unlikely.

Table 3.

Number of diploid and triploid females with sperm in their spermathecae.

Number of females checked
triploid diploid Σ collection date
sperm no sperm sperm no sperm
2 1 3 11.8.2010
1 9 1 3 14 26.8.2011
1 34 1 36 25.8.2015
1 16 1 18 21.8.2016
5 59 2 5 71 totals

COI barcoding

DNA was isolated from alcohol preserved thorax parts of the cytologically studied individuals. A COI fragment of 638 nucleotides was sequenced from 57 triploid parthenogenetic females and 12 diploids (7 females and 5 males) from the Turku population. All triploids shared the same haplotype which was different from that of the diploids. These haplotypes differed by a particular transversion at the position 192, T (Turku 1 haplotype, MF978762) in triploids and A (Turku 2 haplotype, MF978763) in diploids. These data, therefore, demonstrated that triploid parthenogenetic from Turku produced exclusively triploid offspring. The haplotype diversity in the Turku population was low, but was much higher in Vorkuta. Turku 1 haplotype was also found in Vorkuta (2/11 females). In addition, three specific haplotypes from Vorkuta were found, Vorkuta 1 (1/11 females), Vorkuta 2 (5/11 females) and Vorkuta 3 (3/11 female) differing from Turku 1 by either a single nucleotide (Vorkuta 1 and 2) or three nucleotides (Vorkuta 3) (MF978764-MF978766).


Our findings show that details of parthenogenesis in C. ledi are similar to those found previously in C. myrtilli (Nokkala et al. 2015). Parthenogenetic females of C. ledi are triploid showing apomictic oogenesis in which normal meiosis is replaced by a modified mitosis. In addition to triploid females, there were also diploids showing normal chiasmate meiosis. Moreover, the presence of diploid females among obligate triploid parthenogenetic females was discovered for the first time in populations of C. myrtilli collected at various altitudes on the hill Rindhovda in southern Norway (Nokkala et al. 2015). Diploid females showing conventional meiosis were found at frequencies similar to those of rare males at three different altitudes. The highest percentage of both diploid females and males, 10%, was found in the high altitude (1000 m) population, above the tree line. Comparison of frequencies of diploids at different altitudes showed that environmental factors, like altitude, seem to significantly affect the production of diploids (Nokkala et al. 2015). The findings that rare males in those populations were nonfunctional, producing only diploid sperm (Nokkala et al. 2013), on one hand, and the fact that diploids showed the same COI haplotype as triploid females, on the other hand, collectively suggested that diploids resulted from reversions from triploidy and that the frequency of these reversions seemed to be influenced by environmental factors, e.g. altitude. In addition, reversions resulted in both males and diploid females with a similar frequency (Nokkala et al. 2015).

Haplotype diversity in the Turku population of C. ledi was extremely low, where the two recorded haplotypes differed by a single transition. However, much higher diversity was found in the Vorkuta population showing four different haplotypes among the small number of females studied. The close similarity of haplotypes Vorkuta 1 and Vorkuta 2 to that of Turku 1 suggests common ancestry. In contrast, Vorkuta 3 haplotype differed from all other haplotypes found in the population by three nucleotide changes, one of these being a transversion, indicating different origin of this haplotype.

In C. ledi triploid females and diploid females and males displayed different COI haplotypes. Our results prove that triploid females reproduce via obligate thelytoky. Those females, therefore, do not produce diploid females or males. To account for the occurrence of diploid individuals, it is tempting to speculate on the possibility of independent bisexual reproduction. Potentially, reproduction of this kind is possible, since diploid females display normal chiasmate meiosis and males despite some disturbances show virtually normal meiosis. Two observations, however, make bisexual reproduction unlikely. Firstly, the frequency of males in populations at Turku after the drop-down of diploids is very low and is the same magnitude or clearly below 10% like that of rare males in oribatid mites (Palmer and Norton 1990), in Artemia Leach, 1819 species (Maccari et al. 2013), or in C. myrtilli populations (Nokkala et al 2013). Secondly, those males do not discriminate against triploid females making bisexual reproduction highly unlikely. An alternative explanation implies that rare, still undiscovered triploid females which share the same haplotype with diploids are responsible for the production of diploid females and males via reversion from triploidy to diploidy. This means that the genotypes of triploid females would greatly affect their ability to produce diploids. In turn, this would also mean that C. ledi is an obligate parthenogenetic. However, additional studies are needed to confirm this suggestion.

Although in the short term it is difficult to see any advantage for the production of diploids in the long run they can provide further evolutionary opportunities for a parthenogenetic taxon. It is known that functional rare males can mate with closely related sexual females to give rise to a new parthenogenetic lineage. This type of parthenogenesis, known as contagious parthenogenesis (Simon et al. 2003), was analyzed in detail in Daphnia pulex Leydig, 1860 (Paland et al. 2005) and brine shrimps of the genus Artemia (Maccari et al. 2013). The origin of contagious parthenogenesis was also proven in the laboratory for D. pulex (Innes and Herbert 1988), for the aphid Myzus persicae (Sulzer, 1776) (Blackman 1972) and for Artemia spp. (Maccari et al. 2014). Apparently, new parthenogenetic lineages of contagious origin can also be produced by diploid females found in C. myrtilli (Nokkala et al. 2015) and in C. ledi (the present study), if these females are mated with males of a coexisting sexual species. The origin of contagious parthenogenesis could more easily occur via diploid females than through males as they are functional (or show normal meiosis) even in the case when males are nonfunctional (Nokkala et al. 2015). If both diploid females and functional rare males exist in a population, mating between diploids could occasionally result in diploid offspring, in spite of the fact that males do not discriminate against triploid females. Potentially, this could lead to the origin of a new bisexual species from a parthenogenetic lineage. This can also be the case in oribatid mites. Domes et al. (2007) considered phylogenetic relationships between certain taxa belonging to seven families of the oribatid mite group Desmonomata and concluded that a parthenogenetic lineage could evolve to a new parthenogenetic lineage or even to a new bisexual species. Apparently, the evolutionary potential of parthenogenetic lineages is high, complex and far more diverse than previously understood.


Parthenogenetic females of C. ledi are triploid with apomictic meiosis. Triploid females reproduce via obligate parthenogenesis. We also suggest that rare males and diploid females, if present, are produced by triploid females by reversions from triploidy to diploidy. This probably demonstrates how a parthenogenetic taxon can give rise either to a new parthenogenetic lineage or even to a new bisexual species.


Our sincere thanks go to Dr Gokhman for his valuable suggestion for improving the text. The financial support from the Russian Science Foundation (grant no. 14-14-00541) is gratefully acknowledged.


  • Delmotte F, Leterme N, Bonhomme J, Rispe C, Simon J-C (2001) Multiple routes to asexuality in an aphid species. Proeedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 268: 2291–2299.
  • Domes K, Norton RA, Maraun M, Scheu S (2007) Re-evolution of sexuality breaks Dollo’s law. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104: 7139–7144.
  • Folmer O, Black M, Hoeh W, Lutz R, Vrijenhoek R (1994) DNA primers for amplification of mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit I from diverse metazoan invertebrates. Molecular Marine Biology and Biotechnology 3: 294–299.
  • Gegechkori AM (1985) Some aspects of evolution of psyllids ‘Metsniereba’ (Sc. Publ. ), (world fauna). Tbilisi, 302 pp. [in Russian, with English summary and contents]
  • Innes DJ, Herbert PDN (1988) The origin and genetic basis of obligate parthenogenesis in Daphnia pulex. Evolution 42: 1024–1035.
  • Kuznetsova VG, Nokkala S, Maryańska-Nadachowska A (1997) Karyotypes, sex chromosome systems, and male meiosis in Finnish psyllids (Homoptera: Psylloidea). Folia Biologica, Kraków, 45: 143–152.
  • Kuznetsova VG, Labina ES, Shapoval NA, Maryanska-Nadachowska A, Lukhtanov VA (2012) Cacopsylla fraudatrix sp.n. (Hemiptera: Psylloidea) recognized from testis structure and mitochondrial gene COI. Zootaxa 3547: 55–63.
  • Maccari M, Gómez A, Hontoria F, Amat F (2013) Functional rare males in diploid parthenogenetic Artemia. Journal of Evolutionary Biology 26: 1934–1948 .
  • Maccari M, Amat F, Hontoria F, Gomez A (2014) Laboratory generation of new parthenogenetic lineages supports contagious parthenogenesis in Artemia. Peer J 2: e439.
  • Martens K (1998) Sex and ostracods: a new synthesis. In: Schön I, Martens K (Eds) Sex and Parthenogenesis: Evolutionary Ecology of Reproductive Modes in Non-Marine Ostracods.Backhuys Publishers, Leiden, 295–322.
  • Nokkala S, Maryańska-Nadachowska A, Kuznetsova VG (2008) First evidence of polyploidy in Psylloidea (Homoptera, Sternorrhyncha): a parthenogenetic population of Cacopsylla myrtilli (W. Wagner, 1947) from northeast Finland is apomictic and triploid. Genetica 133: 201–205.
  • Nokkala C, Kuznetsova VG, Nokkala S (2013) Meiosis in rare males in parthenogenetic Cacopsylla myrtilli (Wagner, 1947) (Hemiptera, Psyllidae) populations from northern Europe. Comparative Cytogenetics 7: 241–251.
  • Nokkala C, Kuznetsova VG, Nokkala S (2015) Rare diploid females coexist with rare males: a novel finding in triploid parthenogenetic populations in the psyllid Cacopsylla myrtilli (W. Wagner, 1947) (Hemiptera, Psylloidea) in northern Europe. Genetica 143: 589–595.
  • Ossiannilsson F (1972) On Trioza viridula (Zett.) and two related species breeding on Cirsium (Hem., Psylloidea). Entomologica Scandinavica 3: 59–68.
  • Ossiannilsson F (1992) The Psylloidea (Homoptera) of Fennoscandia and Denmark. Fauna Entomologica Scandinavica 26: 1–347.
  • Palmer SC, Norton RA (1990) Further experimental proof of thelytokous parthenogenesis in Oribatid mites (Acari: Oribatida: Desmonomata). Experimental and Applied Acarology 8: 149–159.
  • Rispe C, Bonhomme J, Simon J-C (1999) Extreme lifecycle and sex ratio variation among sexually produced clones of the aphid Rhopalosiphum padi (Homoptera: Aphididae). Oikos 86: 254–264.
  • Simon J-C, Leterme N, Latorre A (1999) Molecular markers linked to breeding system differences in segregating and natural populations of the cereal aphid Rhopalosiphum padi L. Molecular Ecology 8: 965–973.
  • Simon J-C, Delmotte F, Rispe C, Crase T (2003) Phylogenetic relationships between parthenogens and their sexual relatives: the possible routes to parthenogenesis in animals. Biological Journal of the Linnaean Society 79: 151–163.
  • Snyder DW, Opperman CH, Bird DM (2006) A method for generating Meloidogyne incognita males. Journal of Nematology 38: 192–194.
  • Taberley G (1988) Recherches sur la parthénogenèse thélytoque de deux espèces d’acariens oribatides: Trypochtonius tectorum (Berlese) et Platynpthrus peltifer (Koch). IV Observation sur les males ataviques. Acarologia 29: 95–107.
  • Vershinina A, Kuznetsova V (2016) Parthenogenesis in Hexapoda: Entognatha and non-holometabolous insects. Journal of Zoological Systematics and Evolutionary Research 54(4): 257–268.