Research Article |
Corresponding author: Alicia Basso Abraham ( abasso@agro.uba.ar ) Academic editor: Vladimir Gokhman
© 2015 Natalia Forneris, Gabriel Otero, Ana Pereyra, Gustavo Repetto, Alejandro Rabossi, Luis Quesada-Allué, Alicia Basso Abraham.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Forneris NS, Otero G, Pereyra A, Repetto G, Rabossi A, Quesada-Allué LA, Basso AL (2015) High chromosomal variation in wild horn fly Haematobia irritans (Linnaeus) (Diptera, Muscidae) populations. Comparative Cytogenetics 9(1): 31-50. https://doi.org/10.3897/CompCytogen.v9i1.8535
|
The horn fly, Haematobia irritans is an obligate haematophagous cosmopolitan insect pest. The first reports of attacks on livestock by H. irritans in Argentina and Uruguay occurred in 1991, and since 1993 it is considered an economically important pest. Knowledge on the genetic characteristics of the horn fly increases our understanding of the phenotypes resistant to insecticides that repeatedly develop in these insects. The karyotype of H. irritans, as previously described using flies from an inbred colony, shows a chromosome complement of 2n=10 without heterochromosomes (sex chromosomes). In this study, we analyze for the first time the chromosome structure and variation of four wild populations of H. irritans recently established in the Southern Cone of South America, collected in Argentina and Uruguay. In these wild type populations, we confirmed and characterized the previously published “standard” karyotype of 2n=10 without sex chromosomes; however, surprisingly a supernumerary element, called B-chromosome, was found in about half of mitotic preparations. The existence of statistically significant karyotypic diversity was demonstrated through the application of orcein staining, C-banding and H-banding. This study represents the first discovery and characterization of horn fly karyotypes with 2n=11 (2n=10+B). All spermatocytes analyzed showed 5 chromosome bivalents, and therefore, 2n=10 without an extra chromosome. Study of mitotic divisions showed that some chromosomal rearrangements affecting karyotype structure are maintained as polymorphisms, and multiple correspondence analyses demonstrated that genetic variation was not associated with geographic distribution. Because it was never observed during male meiosis, we hypothesize that B-chromosome is preferentially transmitted by females and that it might be related to sex determination.
Karyotypes, genetic variability, population structure, B-chromosome, H-banding, evolution, chromosomal rearrangements
The economic importance of the horn fly, Haematobia irritans (Linnaeus, 1758) (Diptera: Muscidae) is based on its role as an obligate bloodsucking ectoparasite that plagues cattle around the world (
Here we for the first time analyze wild populations of H. irritans which have recently established in the Southern Cone of South America and exhibit considerable karyotypic diversity. The only related study is the analysis of genotypic variability in three horn fly populations from Brazil, Colombia and Dominican Republic, which was assessed by random amplification of polymorphic DNA (
This study was carried out on private lands, with kind permission from the landowners. For data regarding permissions for field collecting, please contact the corresponding author. Furthermore, we previously confirmed that no official permission was required for this field work, as it did not involve any endangered or protected species.
Sampling of adults from different populations of H. irritans feeding on cattle was performed from 2004 to 2010 on private lands at the following main stations in Argentina: Ferreyra in Córdoba Province (31°56.67'S; 61°01.0'W); Trancas in Tucumán Province (26°21.66'S; 65°03.0'W); and Bolivar in Buenos Aires Province (35°50.0'S; 64°01.0'W). Sampling of adult H. irritans from Uruguay was performed in Palmitas (33°25.0'S; 58°07.0'W). Under normal weather, populations of H. irritans develop in these countries from early spring (October) to the beginning of fall (late March) (
Adults were collected on livestock with a sweep net and transferred using positive phototropism to cages with rags soaked with 0.05% sodium citrate-added bovine blood as food source (
Mitosis and meiosis were studied in neuroblasts of sub-esophageal ganglia of third-instar larvae and in spermatocytes of pharate and freshly eclosed adults respectively. Unfortunately, it was logistically impossible to simultaneously dissect brains and gonads in the same larvae.
Ganglia were dissected in a drop of insect Ringer’s solution (
Testes of pharate adult males (120 h after puparium formation) and eclosed adults up to 36 h after emergence were used (
Mitotic chromosome spreads from cerebral ganglia were C-banded using Ba(OH)2 treatment at 27–29 °C for 7 min and stained with 5% Giemsa Gurr (Merck, Germany) solution in phosphate buffer having pH=6.8 (
Multiple Correspondence Analysis (MCA) is a method of factorial analysis that transforms a set of categorical or qualitative variables into a small number of orthogonal variables (
Chromosomes of four wild horn fly populations from Argentina and Uruguay were studied by cytological analysis of mitotic and meiotic metaphases. Brains of 232 third-instar larvae from three locations (Ferreyra, n=134; Bolivar, n=25; Palmitas, n=73) and testes of 55 individuals from three locations (Ferreyra, n=16; Trancas, n= 14; Palmitas, n=25) were analyzed.
Brain cell preparations from 72 to 96-hour third-instar larvae with empty guts showed mitotic pro-metaphases, metaphases and anaphases. Somatic pairing was observed in metaphase plates as reported for other dipterans (
Most specimens (n=150) were analyzed from Ferreyra. The most frequent chromosome number from this location was 2n=10, both on preparations from brains and testes. We arbitrarily defined the corresponding chromosome set as the reference karyotype (Karyotype I).
Karyotype I showed two metacentric chromosomes (pairs 2 and 5) and three sub-metacentric chromosomes (pairs 1, 3 and 4) (Fig.
Reference karyotype of H. irritans with 2n=10. a Giemsa stained C-banded mitotic metaphase from larval brain; arrow indicates satellite on chromosome 3, sc: secondary constriction b Idiogram of the C-banded haploid set c Hoechst 33258 stained H-banded mitotic metaphase from larval brain d Idiogram of the H-banded set e–f Orcein stained meiotic metaphases II from testis; both figures were observed in the same individual. a, c, f arrow indicates satellite on chromosome 3. sc: secondary constriction on chromosome 2.
Frequency distribution of karyotypes within populations of H. irritans from Argentina and Uruguay. sat: Chromosome carrying satellite; (a) grouping of karyotype formulae in the Multiple Correspondence Analysis.
A. Frequent karyotypes | Ferreyra n=150 | Bolivar n=25 | Trancas n=14 | Palmitas n=98 | (a) |
Chromosome number 2n=10 | |||||
2M + 3SM | |||||
Karyotype I (reference karyotype) 2M (2, 5) + 3SM (1, 3, 4); 3 sat |
0.40 | 0.24 | 0 | 0.44 | 1 |
Karyotype II 1 sat | 0.08 | 0 | 0.57 | 0.01 | 1 |
Karyotype III 2, 5 sat | 0 | 0.24 | 0 | 0 | 1 |
Karyotype IV 3SM (2,3,4); 2 sat | 0.02 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 |
1M + 4SM | |||||
Karyotype V (inversion) 1M (2) + 4SM (1, 3, 4, 5); 1 sat |
0.02 | 0 | 0.43 | 0.02 | 3 |
Chromosome number 2n = 11 | |||||
2M + 3SM + B | |||||
Karyotype VI (translocation 1-5) 2M (1, 2) + 3SM (3, 4, 5) + B; 3 sat |
0.32 | 0 | 0 | 0.43 | 4 |
1M + 4M/SM + B | |||||
Karyotype VII (inversion) 1M (2) + 4M/SM (1, 3, 4, 5) + B; 2 sat |
0.007 | 0.40 | 0 | 0 | 5 |
B. Rare karyotypes | Ferreyra n=150 |
Bolivar n=25 | Trancas n=14 |
Palmitas n=98 |
|
Chromosome number 2n=10 | |||||
5SM | |||||
Karyotype VIII 5 SM (1, 2, 3, 4, 5) |
0 | 0 | 0 | 0.01 | 6 |
1M/SM up to 5M/SM, chromosomal polymorphisms with complex rearrangements | |||||
Karyotype IX (translocation 2-4) 1M (5) + 3SM (1, 3, 4) + 1M/SM (2); 2 sat |
0.013 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 6 |
Karyotype X (translocation 2-3) 1M (5) + 2SM (1, 4)+ 2M/SM (2, 3); 2 sat |
0.047 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 6 |
Karyotype XI 1M (2) + 2SM (3, 4) + 2M/SM (1, 5); 1, 5 sat |
0 | 0 | 0 | 0.01 | 6 |
Karyotype XII 1M (2) + 2SM (3, 4) + 2M/SM (1, 5); 2, 5 sat |
0.007 | 0 | 0 | 0.01 | 6 |
Karyotype XIII (inversion on chromosome 4) 2SM (1, 3) + 3M/SM (2, 4, 5) |
0.013 | 0 | 0 | 0.02 | 6 |
Karyotype XIV (inversions) 1M (5) + 1SM (2) + 3M/SM (1, 3, 4) |
0.007 | 0 | 0 | 0,01 | 6 |
Karyotype XV (translocations) 1SM (4) + 4M/SM (1, 2, 3, 5); 2 sat |
0.02 | 0.04 | 0 | 0 | 6 |
Karyotype XVI 5 M/SM (1, 2, 3, 4, 5) |
0.006 | 0 | 0 | 0.01 | 6 |
Chromosome number 2n = 11 | |||||
Mosaic specimens carrying nuclei with free or attached B chromosomes: formulae with heteromorphic pairs: SM ≠ SM+B | |||||
Karyotype XVII (inversion on chromosome 4) 2M (2, 5) + 2SM (1, 3) + [1SM+B] (4); 2, 3 sat |
0.02 | 0.04 | 0 | 0.01 | 7 |
Karyotype XVIII (inversion on chromosome 3) 1M(2) + 2SM(1, 4) + 1M/SM (5) + [1SM+B] (3); 2 sat |
0.007 | 0 | 0 | 0.01 | 7 |
Karyotype XIX (inversions on chromosomes 3, 4) 2M (2, 5) + 1SM(1)+ [2SM+B] (3, 4); 2 sat |
0.013 | 0.04 | 0 | 0.01 | 7 |
Total | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 |
C-banding of karyotype I allowed for detection of satellites (Fig.
H-banded karyotype I is documented on Fig.
Using karyotype I as the reference one, somatic chromosomal polymorphisms affecting chromosome number and/or morphology were detected. Cytological preparations with 2n=11 but without a heteromorphic chromosome pair were selected. This karyotype is formed due to presence of an acrocentric chromosome carrying a small C-positive short arm (Fig.
Chromosome variants in H. irritans. a–f mitotic plates from larval brain cells. a Giemsa C-banded metaphase plate with 2n=11 and karyotype VI; black arrow indicates B-chromosome, white arrow indicates relocation of secondary constriction on the curved long arm of one homologue of pair 3, “s” indicates satellite on chromosome 3 b Composite C-banding idiogram showing some chromosome variants found in different specimens c Giemsa C-banded metaphases with 2n=11 found in the same larva with karyotype VII; white arrow indicates B-chromosome, black arrow indicates satellite on metacentric chromosome 2 d Hoechst 33258 stained prometaphase with 2n=11 carrying complex rearrangements; white arrow indicates B-chromosome e Giemsa stained C-banded metaphase with 2n=10 and heteromorphic pairs 3 and 4; black arrows indicate satellites on chromosomes 1 and 5, white arrows indicate both long arms of pair 3 with one of them carrying an attached B-chromosome e1 anaphase with a bridge e2 metaphase from the same specimen as in e and e1; white arrow indicates rearrangement in one of the homologues of pair 3, black arrow on pair 4 f Hoechst 33258 stained metaphases with 2n=10 and karyotype XV carrying complex rearrangements g Orcein stained meiotic metaphase II from testis with karyotype V; white arrow indicates satellite on chromosome 1.
We identified 19 main chromosomal profiles in Argentina and Uruguay (Table
Chromosome variants in H. irritans. Mitotic plates from larval brain cells. a Two C-banded metaphases with karyotype XVIII, one with 2n=11 (2n=10+B) and the other with 2n=10 with free and attached B-chromosomes (white and black arrows respectively) b1 and b2 Hoechst 33258 stained metaphase and prometaphase of the same specimen with karyotype IV; arrows indicate rearranged pairs 1 and 2 c Hoechst 33258 stained metaphase and prometaphase c1 heteromorphisms of pairs 1 (dashed yellow arrow), 4 and 5 (dotted arrows) and the nucleolus close to chromosome 2 (dashed white arrow), expression of ribosomal DNA located on secondary constriction on chromosome 2 (white arrow) c2 H-banded karyotype with heteromorphisms; arrows indicate rearrangements on prometaphase chromosomes d C-banded incomplete metaphase with chromosomal pairs 1 and 3 (dotted arrow); white arrow indicates pair 1 carrying heterozygous inversion.
Karyotypes composed of two metacentric and three submetacentric chromosomes (formula 2M + 3SM) are represented by variants I, II, III (Table
Karyotypes with 2n=11 (2n=10+B) and formula 2M + 3SM + B correspond to karyotype VI (Fig.
Rare karyotypes (Table
Within the Ferreyra population, karyotype I (2n=10) and karyotype VI (2n=11) were present in 40% and 32% of the insects respectively (Table
Within the Bolivar population, 52% flies had 2n=10. The frequency of karyotype I was 24%. Interestingly, karyotype III with the same frequency and satellites on chromosome 2 was unique to this population (Table
In the Trancas population, only a small sample was studied on the basis of male meiosis. All the insects had karyotype II (2M + 3SM) or karyotype V (1M + 4SM) (Fig.
In the Palmitas population, karyotypes I (2n=10) (44%) and VI (2n=11) (43%) were dominant. Although 56% insects carried rearrangements, flies having 2n=11 prevailed (46%; Table
MCA produced 14 axes from 14 nominal variables (see Materials and Methods). From these, we have chosen seven factors that explained 92.25% of the whole variation. Graphical displays constructed from cluster analysis obtained from those factors, were used to summarize proximities between the specimens and to show associations between the categorical variables. The dendrogram (Fig.
Clustering and spatial distribution of H. irritans. a The most significant discrimination is obtained by the first three axes: karyotypes, satellites and zygotic number of chromosomes, and therefore the three clusters are the most representative. Texas individuals (
Cluster 1 (n=141) is characterized by individuals from groups 1 and 3 (Table
Cluster 2 (n=56) is characterized by all individuals of groups 2, 5, 6 and 7 (Table
Cluster 3 (n=90) is characterized by individuals with 2n=11, of group 4 and with a satellite on chromosome 3; it is composed by 32% of Ferreyra individuals and 43% of Palmitas individuals (Table
The specimens were represented in three-dimensional graphical displays constructed using the first three factorial axes (Fig.
This study is the first chromosomal analysis of recently established wild populations of the horn fly, originally introduced in Brazil in 1983, in the Southern Cone of South America. We believe that the karyotype study provides a basic tool for understanding the population dynamics. Unfortunately, this research is limited by the lack of a full-cycle laboratory rearing technique of the horn fly.
We here document chromosomal rearrangements that affect the chromosome number and morphology. We also confirm that the main chromosome number in H. irritans is 2n=2x=10. For the first time we show the existence of an extra chromosome in three populations, resulting in the presence of chromosome sets with 2n=11 (2n=10+B).
Our study showed that the main chromosomal formula for the karyotypes found in Ferreyra, Palmitas, Trancas and Bolivar was 2M + 3SM. Variation found in the populations from Ferreyra, Palmitas and Bolivar (Table
Extra chromosomes were found within karyotypes from Ferreyra, Bolivar and Palmitas, but we could not determine whether it was the same B-chromosome in all cases. A B-chromosome might be derived from a fragmented autosome or a sex chromosome, i.e. a centric fragment derived from amplification of the paracentromeric region (Fig.
Population frequencies of B-chromosomes result from a balance between their transmission rates and their effects on host fitness (
In our studies, the extra chromosomes might be associated with sex determination as the frequencies of individuals with 2n=11 in Ferreyra, Bolivar and Palmitas were 0.367, 0.48 and 0.46 respectively. The extra chromosome was observed in around 50% of larval brains and was not observed in preparations from testes, further suggesting that the B-chromosome is restricted to females. We hypothesize that this B-chromosome is preferentially transmitted by females, and that it might be related to sex determination because it was never observed during male meiosis. Sex chromosomes were previously proposed as ancestors of the Bs (
Although a direct investigation of demographic structure is difficult in natural conditions (
MCA generated three clusters: cluster 1 grouped specimens with 2n=10 from all four populations; cluster 2 grouped rare karyotypes with 2n=10 and 2n=11 as well as insects from Texas (Fig.
Abundant karyotypes were analyzed in two locations, Ferreyra in Argentina and Palmitas in Uruguay. Resilience of genomes to massive introgression through hybridization, can allow for rapid adaptive response to anthropogenic selection (
We confirmed the chromosome set with 2n=10 as the reference karyotype in wild populations of H. irritans invading the Southern Cone of South America. Karyotypic variants were characterized for the first time; half of these variants were 2n=11 due to the presence of a B-chromosome.
The B-chromosome was observed only in mitotic divisions, mainly as a free acrocentric chromosome.
Horn fly control will highly benefit from genetic studies focusing on the understanding of sex determining mechanisms, which are necessary to design appropriate control strategies, as related to the adaptation of these insects to control measures such as insecticides.
We thank Dr. C. Argaraña and Dr. A. Filiberti for providing the Ferreyra specimens. Funding for this project was provided by the ANPCYT-PICT 2003-351, CONICET (Argentina), and the University of Buenos Aires (UBA).